Why postpone the trial and return the case of an 8-year-old girl who was abused by her step-aunt?

On the morning of July 21, the People's Court of Ho Chi Minh City opened a trial for the abuse of an 8-year-old girl to death. After the defense lawyers for the victim petitioned to return the file for additional investigation and consider the biological father of baby VA for murder, the jury decided to postpone the first-instance court hearing to publicize the case.

Lawyer proposes to consider biological father for murder

At 8:20 am on July 21, the trial began to work. The panel said that 2 days before the trial, the panel received a request from lawyer Nguyen Anh Thom and lawyer Tran Thi Ngoc Nu (lawyer to protect the legitimate rights and interests of the victim) to propose public trial of the case; determined the injury rate of the victim on the days 7, 10, 11 and 12-12-2021 and identified defendant Nguyen Kim Trung Thai accomplices with defendant Trang on the crime of murder.

Lawyer Tran Thi Ngoc Nu said that Thai's chain of actions was determined to be the biological father of baby A. but joined with Trang to scold A., directly using dangerous weapons with baby A.

The times Trang beat baby A., Thai were seen directly or monitored through the camera. This action of Thai means that the person who commits the crime with Trang, is the motivation and motivation for Trang to beat little A. savagely.

Although Thai's testimony at the investigating agency was to blame Trang that Thai had prevented and prevented Trang from beating baby A.... but this testimony contradicts the development of the case, with the chain of actions of Thai.

Regarding the request for additional expertise, the representative of the procuracy said that the assessment results that the investigating agency had carried out were grounded, so it was suggested that the trial panel continue to work. After hearing the recommendations, the trial panel entered into a discussion.

Postponing the trial

After deliberation, the jury said that for the lawyer's proposal to protect the interests of the victim, asking to change the jurisdiction of the court, the jury said that the victim in the case was NTVA's nephew when he died when he was only 8 years old. age, so the case falls under the jurisdiction of the Juvenile and Family Court.

According to the jury, this case belongs to the case that must be tried in secret. However, in this case, the defendant was prosecuted especially seriously, was interested in the public opinion and the victim's representative did not request a closed trial, so the case was tried publicly to educate, prevent and deter. shared.

The jury thought that the recommendation of additional injury assessment for VA on the 7th, 10th, 11th and 12th December 2021 was grounded.

As for the proposal to change the crime, the jury said that after the results of additional investigation, the panel will consider and consider it.

Since then, the trial panel has decided to return the additional investigation file. The reopening time for the trial will be announced by the Court at a later date.

According to the indictment, NTVA's grandchild (born in 2013) is the biological child of Nguyen Kim Trang Thai and Nguyen Thi Hanh. In August 2020, Thai and Hanh divorced. Thai was assigned by the District 1 People's Court to take care of and raise A.

Around September 2020, Nguyen Vo Quynh Trang came to live as husband and wife with Thai at an apartment in Saigon Pearl apartment building. A. is also staying with Thai and Trang since this time.

Around October 2021, due to the COVID-19 epidemic situation, A. A. studied online at home, Thai assigned Trang to stay at home to take care of and tutor A.

During the process of living together from December 7, 2021 to December 22, 2021, Trang repeatedly beat and tortured the wild with her hands, feet, wooden sticks, whips, metal rods (connecting pipes of vacuum cleaners) man grandchild A. in many different ways, for many days, many hours.

There were days when Trang beat up A. in a state of no clothes, got down on her knees and raised her arms high, forcing A. to go into the doghouse with the dog, to keep her pillow in the doghouse...

Thai many times looked directly and witnessed Trang beat grandson A. but did not intervene, but also repeatedly held a tree with Trang to scold, beat and torture grandson A.

It can be seen that the case of an 8-year-old girl has caused a wave of anger in public opinion over the past time. A large number of people came to the court gate, carrying placards expressing sympathy for the baby, as well as resentment at the cruel behavior of the Trang - Thai couple.

The biological father of an 8-year-old girl was unmasked by the maid: Ignore the child, give all rights to the mistress Hoàng Phúc09:07:10 24/07/2022Ms. LTT (the maid of an 8-year-old girl's family) said that Thai used to be a person who loved and pampered her children, but since living with a new love, she completely ignored VA. In the past few days, the incident of NTVA girl (an 8-year-old girl who did not survive the...