In the case of cadres' error of alcohol concentration of female students in Ninh Thuan, the lawyer said: "It is not possible to discipline"

Lawyer Tuan Ngo said that it is necessary to clarify the issue of whether or not the problem of forging papers and documents falsifies the case file. This will prevent the problem of taking advantage of the medical profession to do unethical things.

As previously reported by the media, on June 28 in Ninh Thuan province, a very serious traffic accident occurred. The victim was identified as Ho Hoang Anh (18 years old), a student at Le Quy Don High School for the Gifted. Around 8:00 am, Mr. Hoang Van Minh drove his car from the direction of Binh Son marine park to square 16-4 and turned right to enter the headquarters of Vietinbank, Ninh Thuan province branch in Phan Rang - Thap Cham city.

At this time, the car from behind collided with the motorbike of female student Hoang Anh, causing her death. At the time of the accident, teachers and friends of Le Quy Don school were very sorry when Hoang Anh and her friends were completing the procedures for the 2022 high school graduation exam. During 12 years of school, the female student had academic results. good, take care. It is known that Mr. Hoang Van Minh is a major, Financial Assistant of Regiment 937 (370 Division, Air Defense - Air Force). During working with the authorities, Mr. Minh admitted to using the phone while driving by Bluetooth (wireless connection).

On July 13, the result of alcohol concentration of female student Ho Hoang Anh was 0.79 mg/100 ml of blood, surprising. Disagreeing with this, Hoang Anh's biological father sent a complaint to the authorities. The family was also upset when social media spread a lot of information about female students using alcohol, getting drunk, and then having an accident. This directly affects the honor and morality of his daughter.

On August 2, Mr. Thai Phuong Phien, director of the hospital, admitted that there were errors in the testing process. The test technician did not do it correctly and completely, lacked the verification step, but signed and returned the results. Talking about the result of the daughter's alcohol content being vindicated, Hoang Anh's biological father partly relieved the burden, wanting to punish the right person for the right crime before the pain of losing his child was too great. "I feel relieved and reassured because I have vindicated my son in matters related to his alcohol content and morality. To some extent, it helps my daughter to have peace of mind in the nine springs" - the victim's father shared.

On August 9, the leader of Ninh Thuan General Hospital said: The Disciplinary Committee of this hospital held a disciplinary meeting for individuals related to errors in alcohol testing of female students. grade 12.

From a legal perspective, recently, lawyer Tuan Ngo (Head of Office at ATN LAW FIRM) has expressed his opinion. Lawyers said that disciplining the above officers was not enough of a deterrent. Lawyer Tuan Ngo emphasized, it is necessary to clarify information whether or not the forging of papers and documents affects the case file. At the same time, prevent the abuse of medical ethics to violate the law.

Nguyen shared by Lawyer Tuan Ngo:

Discipline is not enough!

According to information from Vnexpress online newspaper, on the afternoon of August 9, 2022, Ninh Thuan Provincial General Hospital organized a discipline of 5 people for erroneously testing the alcohol concentration of 12th grade female students in Phan Rang city. Of the five people disciplined, three were warned, and the other two were reprimanded. This move of the hospital after more than a month of a car crash, driven by Major Hoang Van Minh (36 years old, financial assistant of Regiment 937), caused the death of female student Ho Hoang Anh, according to me. It is too late and not enough of a deterrent.

I think that a normal student who does not drink alcohol and does not use stimulants cannot have any scientific basis to give a test result of Ho Hoang Anh's alcohol concentration of 0. .79 mg / 100 ml of blood." In this situation, if it is not forged results, then it is to exchange test results of other people, it is difficult to have a more reasonable alternative. If the above happens in fact, it is also a serious violation of medical ethics, a violation of social ethics and a serious violation of the law and has enough elements to constitute a crime if it is determined. the relationship and agreement of this team with the people involved in the car crash.

Therefore, if the leadership of Ninh Thuan Provincial General Hospital shows its responsibility and compensates for the mental damage to the victim's family, it is necessary to transfer the file to the provincial/city police investigation agency. to investigate, verify and clarify whether or not their agency's papers and documents are forged or other acts falsifying the case files. Only then will the leaders here fulfill their responsibilities and show responsibility to society; prevent and deter the abuse of the medical profession to do unethical things.

Don't let public opinion have to wave again, the truth will be exposed because then, all explanations and fallacies have become too late...