The YouTuber group filming the HCMC Traffic Police on duty, is it monitoring or hindering?

Social networks are stirring up a clip recording the scene of a YouTuber group filming the Ho Chi Minh City Traffic Police on duty with the reason of "supervising" the public service, but being asked by the traffic police to avoid going outside the target area for the traffic police to work. The incident happened in the early morning of February 22, the traffic police appeared in the clip as the patrol team of the Phu Lam Traffic Police Team, on duty near the Vinh Loc Industrial Park (Binh Tan District). So what should be done to monitor the traffic police?

Specifically, a clip about 50 minutes long was shared, a group of young men holding their phones to film the traffic police and stream it to YouTube to record the fight scene. This group constantly used the excuse that they were monitoring the work of the traffic police, so they were allowed to film, and the traffic police asked the youth group to go out of the target area to do their duty. But many cameramen also constantly shouted that the traffic police were encroaching on the roadside and asked who let the traffic police do the topic of alcohol content at this location?

Traffic police explained that people have the right to supervise but not to check. The clip attracted hundreds of thousands of views and comments. Many people support the supervision of traffic police, but most also believe that this behavior is hindering traffic police from doing their duty.

The traffic police said: " You are supervised, but you stand outside the area to let us work". A young man said: "You leave the nameplate for me to see, but you cover it so you lose perspective. You ask me to come out, you can't. You are encroaching on the sidewalk of pedestrians. You can perform traffic control patrol duty, but you must not encroach on the sidewalk of pedestrians. You do your duty, no one will hinder you."

Traffic police explained: "You go out of this area, you are obstructing the law enforcement, otherwise I will call the ward police. You are just a citizen monitoring, we are on duty. Here we do, there is an inspection force. People have the right to supervise but not to check."

Another person in the traffic police filming group protested: "Do you know that people talk about people to check people? You said I don't have to follow you." This group constantly thinks that the traffic police are encroaching on the sidewalk of pedestrians, asking the traffic police how much this fine is. After that, the filming team continued to ask the traffic police: "Who let you do the alcohol content seminar here. Show me the planning topic. I'm asking you, I was monitoring you but you were struggling, let me monitor you. Can you get close?"

Also in the clip, a young man wearing a black shirt and mask pushed the shoulder of a member of the filming team to show his reaction to being filmed, then left. The camera crew ran after this man to face him, but he waved his hand to resist. Gathering you to take a video of the tail, a bodyguard intervenes. You turned and shouted, "Always keep watch over the army".

After that, the group of people turned around to ask who the young male traffic police was. The traffic police say they don't know you. A little later, a group of young men appeared dumbfounded when (suspectedly called by the other young man). Standing on the side of the couple, the group of people took a video of each other to prepare the billiards, the "autumn" tree. However, after measuring the car, the guard's eyes were closed, bringing a group of young people to silence when they returned to their homes. The group took a video and followed, but went to the place where the police officer saw him.

Throughout the video, you continuously shoot the muzzle while shouting "continued to compete" because the traffic police used to "scream" in the act of humiliation. You now said that you are "you are in the industry", so you can be "in the middle of the competition" and aim to record a video to "reduce the truth", "help bring the peaceful life" to you. people.

According to the verification of the authorities, the young man in black appeared in the clip and there was a scuffle with the camera crew, a nearby auto mechanic. Feeling frustrated because the filming team took their own pictures, there was a conflict. According to verification with the traffic police, when the group of young men in black clashed with the filming group, the traffic police were not present.

The leader of the Road-Railway Traffic Police Department (PC08) said that people have the right to monitor traffic police through audio and video recording equipment or direct observation, but must ensure the following conditions: do not affect the operation. normal behavior of officers and soldiers while on duty; comply with other relevant laws as prescribed in Circular 67.

"People have the right to supervise the traffic police, but anyone passing by also stops to film, monitor or go to supervise in groups like that, how can the traffic police do their duty when the traffic safety and order situation at the time is not guaranteed. People are allowed to supervise the traffic police according to the provisions of the circular, but are not allowed to check the papers of the traffic police", the leader of PC08 explained.

The leader added: "The supervision must ensure the prescribed distance for the traffic police to do their duty. In the clip, the filming team said that the traffic police set up a checkpoint encroaching on the roadside. It is not correct. For convenience, safety, pay a stake, the car turns on the turn signal to let the traffic participants know, the traffic police also cordon off the area on duty, so it cannot be said to encroach on the roadside."

Lawyer Le Trung Phat, Director of Le Trung Phat Law Firm, said that Circular 67/2019/TT-BCA allows people to supervise the police. "Thus, people no matter what job they are doing (including YouTubers) still have the right to supervise the traffic police force but must comply with the regulations," said lawyer Phat. According to lawyer Phat, YouTubers or people when filming to monitor traffic police need to separate between the traffic police force on duty and the rights of other people's personal images because the recording and video recording of people must be controlled. consent of the person being recorded.

He analyzed: "If YouTubers take personal pictures of violators without their consent, they will be forced to delete them. In case, if this is posted on telecommunications networks, social networks affect the honor. If their reputation causes damage or loss to them, the person being filmed can sue to claim compensation for the damage."

Since last night, the clip is attracting more than 130,000 views and receiving hundreds of comments. What do people think about this surveillance action?

YouTuber "mới nhú" đổ keo 502 vào hàng loạt ổ khoá nhà dân, để lại mảnh giấy kêu gọi đăng ký kênh Jennie08:22:10 18/08/2022Khi vụ việc được fanpage Tuổi trẻ Công an TP Đà Nẵng chia sẻ, nhiều người dùng cho biết tình trạng bị xịt sơn, dán giấy quảng cáo cho kênh YouTube nêu trên đã xuất hiện hơn 1 năm, ở nhiều khu vực của TP Đà Nẵng