Lawsuit related to Le Hoang Phuong: Sponsor released more evidence, demanding 8.6 billion

Recently, the People's Court of Binh Thanh District, Ho Chi Minh City held a first instance trial of a dispute over a brand promotion contract between NA Plastic Surgery Hospital Joint Stock Company and the defendant, Commercial Advertising Joint Stock Company. SV

Miss Le Hoang Phuong (Miss Grand Vietnam 2023) was summoned to participate in the trial as a related person. However, at today's trial, Hoang Phuong was not present but was only an authorized representative.

Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai as a witness was not present in court. He applied for failure to appear according to the summons.

During the trial, NA Hospital withdrew its lawsuit request for compensation for damages, honor and reputation, an amount of 14.9 million VND. At the same time, NA requested the Miss Grand Vietnam 2023 Organizing Committee to request a payment of 8 billion 640 million VND.

During the proceedings, the question and answer session between the Organizing Committee and NA Hospital clarified the completion of the contract Brand promotion contract No. 149/2023/HĐQBTH/SV-2023 (hereinafter referred to as "Contract No. 149" ).

After letting the two sides ask and answer questions related to the dispute over the brand promotion contract between the organizers and NA Hospital, on the afternoon of April 25, the chairman had a question and answer session between the two sides:

The judge presiding over the trial asked NA Hospital to provide a basis for claiming compensation for Contract No. 149, as well as stating what the organizers of Miss Grand Vietnam 2023 had completed in the contract.

After the answers from the lawyer as well as the representative of NA Hospital about the terms that Miss Grand Vietnam organizers had not yet implemented, the jury said that the question was clear but the answer from NA Hospital was not clear and unconfirmed. Identify the obligations that BTC violates.

When asked to quantify and state the basis for requesting compensation from Miss Grand Vietnam 2023 organizers, giving a figure of 8 billion 640 million VND, NA Hospital could not state the basis, only stating that Contract 149 was a contract. package, NA Hospital gives an "approximate" number according to the market price.

In addition, during the trial, representatives of NA Cosmetic Hospital twice requested to suspend the trial. For the first time, the reason given by NA Hospital was to summon a witness to court even though there was an application for trial in absentia and a written statement of opinion, here it was Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai.

The second time, NA Hospital requested to temporarily suspend the trial to collect more evidence.

Near the end of the trial, when the NA representative provided a new document, the brand ambassador contract, the image at the signing ceremony announced Miss Le Hoang Phuong as the brand ambassador of the Cosmetic Hospital. NA

The chairman decided to temporarily suspend the trial due to the appearance of new documents. The jury agreed to let both sides access new evidence and requested that it not be copied, saved, or distributed on social networks.

At the trial, the plaintiff asked SV and Hoang Phuong about the fact that Ms. Phuong was NA's brand representative but at the same time promoted NA and Chiem Quoc Thai doctor company. Is it a violation if two business units sell the same product or service?

SV Company believes that Ms. Phuong did not promote Thai Doctor Company, so SV did not violate the contract. Ms. Phuong is NA's brand ambassador but "not exclusive". Therefore, SV asked the court not to accept the plaintiff's requests.

Ms. Phuong's representative said that this post was on Dr. Thai's personal Facebook page, but Ms. Phuong did not actively post on her personal Facebook page or Fanpage, nor did she make any violating statements about the trade ambassador. signal. Therefore, Ms. Phuong's side believes that she did not commit any violation of the contract between Students and NA

During the organization of the Miss Grand Vietnam 2023 - Miss Grand Vietnam 2023 contest, the organizing committee affirmed that it has fulfilled its obligations to NA hospital fully and effectively, complying with the commitments of the parties. and legal regulations such as using images, documents, logos, names and information provided by partners.

Miss Grand Việt Nam thắng kiện Nhà tài trợ, Lê Hoàng Phương vẫn "có lỗi"? Hoàng Phúc10:22:33 14/06/2024Mới đây, Tòa án Nhân dân quận Bình Thạnh TPHCM tuyên án phiên tòa sơ thẩm vụ kiện tranh chấp hợp đồng quảng bá thương hiệu giữa ban tổ chức Miss Grand Vietnam 2023 và một bệnh viện thẩm mỹ.