Tycoon Duc An conceded to Ngoc Thuy this one thing in court, Phan Nhu Thao expressed his attitude towards her husband's ex-wife?

On September 20, the People's Court of Ho Chi Minh City held a first instance hearing on the case of dispute over property ownership and division of common property after divorce between Mr. Nguyen Duc An (American nationality) and Ms. Pham Thi Ngoc Thuy. . The jury decided to postpone the trial until after October 16.

To date, Phan Nhu Thao has appeared at the City People's Court. HCM to attend the trial on behalf of her husband. Supermodel Ngoc Thuy also arrived quite early. Although he was not present in court, social networks spread the image of male businessman Duc An appearing at the court gate but not entering. He gave his wife a passionate kiss and then left. Phan Nhu Thao also confirmed that her husband took her to court and had to go handle other work. She also believed that it was not necessary for her husband to be present in court because he had authorized his wife and lawyer.

According to the lawyer representing tycoon Duc An, his client agreed to give the defendant ownership of 5 apartments at the Avalon building worth more than 45 billion VND. This is a new proposal in this trial because Mr. An previously asked Ms. Thuy to return the real estate during the marriage that was in Ms. Thuy's name.

Along with this decision to change, Mr. An wants Ms. Thuy to transfer the remaining assets to her two children (15 and 16 years old). At the same time, Ms. Thuy was not allowed to manage and had to hire another unit to take care of this property. During the recent court pause, Mr. An asked his representative to meet Ms. Ngoc Thuy's family and lawyer to make this proposal, but Ms. Thuy did not accept.

According to Mr. An's lawyer, the amount of 47 billion VND and 700,000 USD that Mr. An transferred to her through the bank could not have been made by Ms. Thuy because from 2006 to 2008, Ms. Ngoc Thuy was continuously pregnant and gave birth to 2 children. c.hild. It is impossible that Ms. Thuy does not have a job that generates income, so she cannot own the above assets (estimated at more than 136 billion VND).

Specifically, according to Mr. An's lawyer, the client is an overseas Vietnamese who has done business and created a large fortune in the US. Because Mr. An wanted to repatriate and invest in real estate business in Vietnam, he transferred m.oney back to Thuy to buy properties. This is said to be the reason for the marriage with Ngoc Thuy, to have someone ask to buy property in his name in a context where the law does not yet allow Mr. An (with foreign nationality) to own real estate.

Regarding Ngoc Thuy's claim that the m.oney to buy assets in 2007 and 2008 (more than 136 billion VND) was "money earned from modeling work, working for large corporations or real estate business", the law The lawyer said: "The defendant could not provide documents to prove the origin of the m.oney. During 2007 to 2008, the defendant continuously gave birth to children, so how could he generate an income of millions of dollars to buy real estate? ?".

During the proceedings, Ms. Truong Thi Be (Ngoc Thuy's biological mother) repeatedly told the court that all of her daughter's assets in her name "came from Mr. An's m.oney transfer". Other relatives of Ngoc Thuy also gave similar testimony.

In addition to the documents and evidence proving the origin of the cash flow sent by the plaintiff, Mr. An's defense lawyer also affirmed that the basis to force Thuy to hand over the assets is the judgment recording the agreement of the parties in 1995. 2011 of the Superior Court of California, District of Santa Clara.

In case the court recognizes the disputed assets as common property of husband and wife, Mr. An proposes to divide according to the ratio: Mr. An receives 70%, Ngoc Thuy 30% - for some assets; Some real estate and shares at Binh Minh Company in Vung Tau belong to Mr. An. Mr. An wants to receive the property and will pay Ngoc Thuy an amount equivalent to the value she received.

Meanwhile, the defendant's representative disagreed and asked the court to divide the matter 50/50 because this is property formed during the marriage. And Ngoc Thuy also wants to receive the property and will pay 50% of the value to Mr. An.

After the two sides ended their argument, the representative of the Procuracy said that the litigant presented a lot of new evidence, so he needed time to research it thoroughly before expressing his opinion on resolving the case.

The jury decided to temporarily suspend the trial and reopen it on the afternoon of October 26.

As for Phan Nhu Thao, after the trial ended, on her personal page, Phan Nhu Thao posted a picture of her husband playing with his daughter. What is worth mentioning is that she implicitly sarcasms someone who takes someone else's property as their own without shame. The beauty wrote: ""THREE DIFFERENT VISION". They see that taking other people's (children's) things to make it their own is good and needs to be praised, encouraged and spread. I see... I'm so sorry, honey."

Even though she married a rich man, Phan Nhu Thao was very independent financially. She built many of her own cosmetic and spa brands. Therefore, she has every right to be proud of her labor achievements and not rely on her other half.

Supermodel Ngoc Thuy was demanded by Duc An giant for an additional 78 billion VND before the trial date, Phan Nhu Thao made a strange move Hoàng Phúc14:32:41 08/08/2023The post-divorce property dispute of Dai Duc An and his ex-wife Ngoc Thuy continued to heat up again when the U60 giant listed the properties that he had left his ex-wife in his name, along with the suspicion that the supermodel was deliberately delaying to get rid of her assets.