Rosé (BLACKPINK) was criticized for losing to NingNing (aespa) because of one weakness, fans argued fiercely

Many viewers think that when singing the same song, Rosé (BLACKPINK)'s skills are weaker than aespa junior - Ning Ning.

In the Kpop entertainment industry, the singing ability as well as the vocal technique of female idols is always a controversial topic. In particular, every time the female idols' voices are compared with each other, it will create an unending "war of words".

Recently, a TikTok account specializing in comparing the vocals of Korean idols with more than 100,000 followers uploaded a clip comparing singing techniques between two popular female idols, Rosé (Black Pink) and Ning Ning. (aespa).

Accordingly, Rosé and Ning Ning are both known as the main vocalists in two currently extremely popular Kpop girl groups. While Rosé has always been known for the unique and rare voice of the famous global group BLACKPINK, Ning Ning is also praised for possessing a powerful voice that can reach towering notes. Despite being a "junior" of BLACKPINK, aespa has recently had cult hits, attracting a dizzying increase in the number of fans.

Therefore, when Rosé (BLACKPINK) and NingNing (aespa) coincidentally performed the song If I Aint Got You, of course the vocals of the two popular groups were dissected and analyzed by the public. and sensibility. In the clip posted by the TikTok account that compares the voices of idols, this person commented that both Rosé and Ning Ning have the same weakness when singing, which is often "sour" when hitting high notes.

Accordingly, except for the glare when going up, this clip evaluates that Ning Ning sings without having a nasal (nasal sound), using the technique of continuously changing the voice from chest voice to head voice. pretty good. As for Rosé, she was criticized for having a voice with a lot of nasal (nasal sound), having a high nasal sound.

Immediately, this clip quickly received more than 14,000 interactions and thousands of mixed comments. Accordingly, many comments reacted quite strongly to the fact that Rosé was considered "inferior" compared to juniors in terms of vocals. Even many comments also expressed attacks on the channel owner because of this comparison. Besides, many fans of SM (Ning Ning's management company) think that the singing technical ability of the "chicken" is indisputable and hope that Rosé's fans will acknowledge that she has a problem. nose sound error when singing. Many fans of Rosé expressed that although the idol's technique is controversial, the voice of "Australian rose" is still more emotional and attractive.

The owner of the channel who posted the above clip also confirmed that he was analyzing only on objective opinions, not to attack anyone: "This one I posted about the technique in the same song, I find Ning Ning more than about the toxicity. unique and emotional, vote for Rosé".

Indeed, although Rosé is entangled in many controversies about singing technique, many viewers have to admit that Rosé's voice can be picky, but once you like it, it's hard to resist.

This is not the first time that the topic of Rosé's voice has been controversial. At some of BLACKPINK's concerts, covers performed by Rosé such as You and I, Eyes Nose Lips, Someone you loved... were also strongly criticized by netizens. The main vocalist of the YG girl group was criticized for "singing too much", "singing too much". The female idol is said to have compressed her voice to create a special color in her voice, leading to incomplete pronunciation of words, loss of her inherent deep voice, and fatigue for listeners.

In fact, the voice of the "Australian rose" when he was a trainee was completely different from the present. Specifically, an undisclosed pre-debut video of Rosé was posted on Twitter by a fan, in which she played the guitar while covering the song "When you look me in the eyes".

This video received more than 750,000 views, 32,000 likes after only 12 hours. Many fans praised YG's beauty from a young age. At the age of 15, Rosé already possesses remarkable vocal skills and a unique sweet voice. With outstanding talent, it is not difficult to understand when Rosé has overcome hundreds of contestants to win YG's audition and become the top trainee in the "New girl group" project. Also in 2012, she was introduced to the public by YG through the vocals in the song "Without You" by G-Dragon (Big Bang).

Besides compliments on Rosé's talent, there are also mixed opinions about her voice. Accordingly, many people think that Rosé's voice in the pre-debut era sounded much more attractive and inspiring than now. Fans regretted when the female idol "lost her real voice", no longer able to keep the warm and generous "angel voice" in the past. According to many fans, during vocal training at YG, Rosé was forced to voice, leading to her current voice being harsh, "sour like vinegar", "too much charm" and becoming... difficult to absorb.

Meanwhile, some fans think that Rosé's pre-debut singing style mainly uses the technique of lowering the larynx to thicken the voice, which is not good for the voice. When she practiced at YG, she was trained more professionally.

Rosé caused controversy because of inadvertent internal division, Blackpink forced to disband? Minh Lợi14:51:34 07/02/2025The super hit APT. and the debut full album have brought Rosé countless records and unprecedented achievements. Combined with Bruno Mars, APT. immediately became a global phenomenon, bringing Rosé straight to the top #8 of the Billboard Hot 100 in its first week of release.