Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty

Phúc SenOct 17, 2023 at 15:16

 3  |  0 Discuss  |  Report

Follow on

Famous male journalist Ha Quang Minh has just published a long post, directly criticizing the film Southern Forest Land amid the noise that the film was criticized for distorting history. To put it bluntly, the film director was too rude.

In recent days, the fever of the movie Southern Forest seems to be hitting every box office across the country. Even though it was only released a few days ago, Southern Forest Land has already garnered a huge audience and the number of tickets sold is at the top of the charts. The revenue figure of hundreds of billions is also expected by the film crew to come true in the near future.

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 1

However, not long after its release, Southern Forest Land was immediately accused of distorting history. Accordingly, although the film is based on a Vietnamese historical story, the details and dialogue in the film are misleading, causing the meaning to be distorted. Specifically, the two names Thien Dia Hoi and Nghia Hoa Doan were mentioned in the film, but according to this, many people think of China's Qing Dynasty, which is not accurate for Vietnamese people.

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 2

Recently, journalist Ha Quang Minh also wrote an article speaking out directly about the noise in the Southern Forest Land. He directly criticized the movie and the producer for being too bad. Specifically, the male journalist shared: " When this movie was being filmed, I told 1-2 friends, "This movie is definitely good. Dung is crazy about the South, understands the South so he is sure to produce quality. Before the movie came out, just in the media, we saw controversy over the image of Uncle Ba Phi.

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 3

"I just chuckled. I thought "has anyone ever seen or met Uncle Ba Phi in real life and discussed right and wrong?" Each person will imagine Ba Phi in their own way. And Ba Phi in this Southern Forest Land is the vision of Tran Thanh and Nguyen Quang Dung. Visualization is their own right. Accepting it or not is each person's right."

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 4

"Now that the movie is out in theaters, there is controversy about the role of the Secret Society in the movie. Some people say Thien Dia Hoi, others say Nghia Hoa Doan. Arguing, arguing, only crazy Dung spoke at the press conference The idea is that "the film's setting is moved back to the early 30s and not as faithful as writer Doan Gioi's original work was after 1945".

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 5

"Crazy Dung's explanation to rationalize the presence of secret societies seems reasonable, but in fact, if the image of Nghia Hoa Doan is used in the film, I'm afraid the producer is seriously wrong. According to reality , in the South during the French colonial period, there was no Thien Dia Hoi to fight against the French. Many secret societies existed according to a similar model to Thien Dia Hoi, but there was no Thien Dia Hoi operating like that in the South. A small number of French people ( and some Vietnamese mandarins) used the term Thien Dia Hoi to refer to Southern secret societies only.

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 6

"As for the Chinese secret societies in Cochinchina at that time, three societies emerged: Nghia Hoa Doan, Hoa Xuan Doan and Nghia Hung Doan. Of these three secret merchant societies, only Nghia Hung Doan maintained the spirit of resistance to the French. Nghia Hoa Union only does business and mainly organizes casinos, whorehouses, and dru.g shops. Because many members of Nghia Hung Union lost mone.y i.n Nghia Hoa Union's casinos, there were bloodshed between these two associations. Therefore, using the image of Nghia Hoa Doan as anti-French people in the movie is wrong."

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 7

"What's worth thinking about is even more absurd: "For what reason must we avoid the fact that the novel's setting is after 1945, when the main anti-French force was the Viet Minh? Does the producer have any political intentions when moving the scene so violently? Or are they afraid that the revolutionary atmosphere will make it difficult for the film to sell tickets? And why do the film reviewers at the National Board of Review ignore this extremely sensitive element of politics and historical truth?"

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 8

Ha Quang Minh's shares quickly caused fierce controversy. Currently, the movie Southern Forest Land has just announced that it will edit the dialogue in the movie and re-release it to the public. However, the work has more or less lost points in the public's hearts, causing intense controversy and heavily affecting the work, especially director Nguyen Quang Dung.

Journalist Ha Quang Minh loudly distorted the history of Southern Forest Land and criticized the film for being too dirty - Photo 9

Did you LIKE this article?
Yes
No

Related topics

The Ministry of Culture concluded that about the noise distorting the history of the Southern Forest Land, anyone who continues to defame it will be dealt with

Đức Trí16:10:14 08/11/2023
The film Southern Forest Land officially has a final conclusion from the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism, after uproar and criticism from netizens claiming that the film has content that distorts history. Even more harshly, he announced that he would take action if anyone smeared him.

 1  |  3 Discuss  |  

National Assembly delegate talks about the controversy over the history of Southern Forest Land and publicly supports the film?

Nguyễn Tuyết07:01:38 26/10/2023
Recently, Southern Forest Land is the movie that is said to have received the second most attacks ever. Even people who haven't seen it are competing to insult each other...

 3  |  0 Discuss  |  

University students in Ho Chi Minh City talk about Southern Forest Land when revenue reached the 100 billion mark

Tuyết Ngọc16:57:06 23/10/2023
Recently, students of Ho Chi Minh City University of Ho Chi Minh City had a movie viewing session and interacted with the Southern Forest Land crew to hone their filmmaking skills to serve the Multimedia Industry.

 4  |  0 Discuss  |  

Mai Tai Phen was attacked after her role in Southern Forest Land, the harsh reaction made anti-fans sag

Thanh Phúc10:38:33 23/10/2023
Actor Mai Tai Phen - who played the role of Vo Tong in Southern Forest Land, was involved in controversy right after the film's release. Even sitting idle was also hit and attacked. His response to anti-fans is worth mentioning.

 2  |  0 Discuss  |  

Media expert exposes Southern Forest Land crew's tricks, male stars receive criticism for praising too much

Hoàng Phúc11:41:46 19/10/2023
Being the highest-grossing film at the Vietnamese box office today, Dat Rung Phuong Nam faces many controversies. Nguyen Quang Dung's project received mixed reviews from viewers.

 3  |  0 Discuss  |  

The director of the movie Southern Forest Land responded to public opinion after a series of noise, claiming that the audience was misunderstanding

T.P13:42:07 18/10/2023
Director Nguyen Quang Dung of the film Southern Forest Land has just made an official statement in response to a series of unnecessary noises, accusing the film of distorting history, causing serious impacts over the past several days. .

 2  |  0 Discuss  |  

Rocker Nguyen came out to defend the movie Southern Forest Land, making a harsh statement: Anyone who watches it and criticizes it will be jealous of their eyes.

T.P07:08:02 18/10/2023
Actor Rocker Nguyen has just caused a stir online when he suddenly posted a post defending the noisy distortion of the history of the movie Southern Forest Land. He harshly said that anyone who criticizes a movie is blind to the eyes and doesn't feel enough sense when watching the movie.

 2  |  0 Discuss  |  

Tran Thanh almost cried at the Trung Quan concert, deliberately reminding the audience after the noise of Southern Forest Land

Juni Nguyễn17:11:01 30/10/2023
Male artist Tran Thanh just made a move that caused a stir in public opinion, almost crying and making a meaningful speech at Trung Quan's concert. People simultaneously thought that he was tactfully reminding the audience after the noise of Southern Forest Land.

 3  |  0 Discuss  |  

Huynh Hao Khang: Will the new generation An in "Southern Forest Land" be overshadowed by Hung Thuan's "shadow"?

Gia Linh14:47:03 24/10/2023
Even though he is still young, Hao Khang's acting skills make veteran seniors surprised. It is known that Hao Khang researched, learned and acted according to the most instinctive instincts of a 13-year-old bo.y.

 4  |  0 Discuss  |  

Writer Doan Gioi's family's reaction when Dat Rung Phuong Nam's revenue plummeted?

Snow22:31:43 21/10/2023
Writer Doan Gioi's son-in-law said his whole family was terribly sad because Phuong Nam Forest Land was fiercely discussed online yesterday. Amid the noise, the film's revenue is showing signs of decline.

 5  |  0 Discuss  |  

Hong Thanh teased and played tricks when he promised to pay for tickets to see 'Southern Forest Land', who would have thought that fans would stone him?

Ning Jing16:43:14 20/10/2023
After being texted by a series of viewers asking for mone.y when they felt that the film project Southern Forest Land caused Hong Thanh to hastily delete his post, the actor recently spoke up to clarify everything, unintentionally pushing the matter further. .

 2  |  0 Discuss  |  

Tuan Hung called for tickets to watch Southern Forest Land amid a series of scandals, Duy Manh immediately rectified it

Pinky13:38:44 19/10/2023
Singer Tuan Hung just made a post that caused a stir in public opinion, directly mentioning the name of the movie Southern Forest Land in the midst of a drama storm that distorts history. Publicly calling on people to buy movie tickets, Duy Manh immediately corrected them.

 2  |  0 Discuss  |  

New Miss Cosmonoisy negavPhan Dat Phuong Landiddy was arrested# babymonsterphilips spiritteam africaMrs Phuong HangVo Le Que Anhrapper diddyI attendblackpinklisalight spirit -2ne1)